In round 20 last season, Carlton beat a fading Gold Coast by 39-points at Etihad Stadium.
The Blues outmuscled their opponents from the beginning and were never headed, winning 14.13 (97) to 8.10 (58) and leaving the SUNS facing an uphill battle to play finals.
The pattern of the match would have suggested it was the Blues with their top-eight hopes on the line.
They out-tackled their opponents, were more desperate in pursuit of the contested ball and ran harder to create options for their teammates.
The result left Gold Coast with a 10-9 record, and they could be one game and significant percentage outside the top eight by the end of the round if Collingwood beats West Coast on Sunday.
The player to benefit most from the SUNS falling stocks was tall forward Jarrad Waite, who continued a superb run of form since returning to the team in round 18 to kick five goals and take nine marks.
With his future at Visy Park up in the air, Waite has kicked a total of 12 goals and taken 27 marks in his past three games.
Young Blue Tom Bell, meanwhile, kicked a career-best four goals, while debutant Ciaran Sheehan was able to play a full game on debut, impressing with his ball use.
Meanwhile, Gold Coast midfielder Michael Rischitelli left the game in the second quarter with an apparent hip complaint and Trent McKenzie sat out the fourth quarter with concussion.
Without injured captain Gary Ablett, the SUNS' lack of a game-turner in the midfield was obvious.
Young on-ballers Harley Bennell, Jaeger O'Meara and Dion Prestia have all seen their numbers drop without Ablett, combining for 8.2 fewer possessions a game before Saturday's clash.
Bennell (27 disposals) and O'Meara (26) won their share on Saturday, but didn't impact the contest like they could alongside Ablett. Prestia was tagged out of the game by Andrew Carrazzo.
Sensing an easy kill under an open roof, Carlton put its foot down in the second quarter and kicked four unanswered goals in an 18-minute burst that left them with a match-winning lead at the main break.
Judd burst onto a loose ball in attack and converted on the run, Gibbs took a contested mark in the goal-square and Bell kicked two outstanding goals in three minutes from opposite pockets.
Waite could do no wrong, forcing the SUNS to replace Steven May with Rory Thompson as his opponent, with Thompson performing well in the second half.
Midfielder David Swallow was probably his team's best player on a disappointing day for the SUNS, finishing with nine tackles and 19 possessions.
Gold Coast faces Port Adelaide at Metricon Stadium next week while the Blues square off against Geelong at Etihad Stadium.
CARLTON 4.2 11.6 12.10 14.12 (97)
GOLD COAST 1.1 4.3 5.6 8.10 (58)
GOALS
Carlton: Waite 5, Bell 4, Judd 2, Thomas, Gibbs, McLean
Gold Coast: Harbrow 2, Hall, Martin, Stanley, Swallow, Lynch, O'Meara
BEST
Carlton: Judd, Waite, Simpson, Thomas, Gibbs, Murphy, Bell
Gold Coast: Swallow, O'Meara, Thompson
Official crowd: 28,840 at Etihad Stadium
